Witness the emotional rollercoaster of baseball history as we delve into some of the sport’s most heart-wrenching moments. We’ll take a nostalgic trip through some of the saddest moments in Major League Baseball history. But fair warning, these moments are not for the faint of heart.
Take a front-row seat to moments that transcend the boundaries of mere competition, delving into the heart of the sport where triumph and adversity intertwine. Here are 10 of tear-jerker moments in Major League Baseball history:
This post contains affiliate links. Please read our disclosure.
- 1. Mazeroski’s Walk-Off (1960)
- 2. The Curse of the Bambino (1920)
- 3. Don Denkinger’s Call (1985)
- 4. The Bartman Incident (2003)
- 5. Joe Carter’s Walk-Off (1993)
- 6. Mariners’ Unfulfilled Promise (2001)
- 7. Brooklyn Dodgers’ Move (1957)
- 8. Boston’s Late-Season Collapse (2011)
- 9. Jack Morris’s 10-Inning Shutout (1991)
- 10. The Black Sox Scandal (1919)
1. Mazeroski’s Walk-Off (1960)
One of the most iconic moments in baseball history, the New York Yankees faced heartbreak in the 1960 World Series. In Game 7, Bill Mazeroski’s unforgettable walk-off home run secured a victory for the Pittsburgh Pirates, leaving the Yankees stunned and fans with a bittersweet memory. Watch it here.
2. The Curse of the Bambino (1920)
In a move that would echo through history, the Boston Red Sox traded the legendary Babe Ruth to the New York Yankees in 1920. Little did they know, this decision would usher in the infamous “Curse of the Bambino,” haunting the Red Sox with decades of World Series disappointments. Watch here.
3. Don Denkinger’s Call (1985)
The 1985 World Series witnessed a controversial moment that etched itself into baseball lore. Umpire Don Denkinger’s disputed call in Game 6 favored the Kansas City Royals, contributing to the St. Louis Cardinals’ heartbreaking loss and stirring endless debates among fans. Watch it here.
4. The Bartman Incident (2003)
Steve Bartman became an unwitting symbol of agony for Chicago Cubs fans in 2003. During the NLCS, Bartman’s interference with a crucial play contributed to the Cubs’ defeat against the Florida Marlins, leaving fans to ponder what might have been. Watch here.
5. Joe Carter’s Walk-Off (1993)
The 1993 World Series culminated in heartbreak for the Philadelphia Phillies as Joe Carter’s walk-off home run in Game 6 secured the championship for the Toronto Blue Jays. It was a moment of triumph for the Blue Jays and a poignant farewell for the Phillies. Watch it here.
6. Mariners’ Unfulfilled Promise (2001)
In a season marked by historic success, the Seattle Mariners’ hopes were dashed in the 2001 ALCS. Despite an impressive 116 regular-season wins, the Mariners fell short against the New York Yankees, leaving fans with the sting of unmet expectations. Watch here.
7. Brooklyn Dodgers’ Move (1957)
1957 marked a somber chapter for Brooklyn Dodgers fans as the team, deeply ingrained in the borough’s identity, made a heart-wrenching move to Los Angeles. The departure left a void in Brooklyn and forever altered the landscape of baseball. Watch here.
8. Boston’s Late-Season Collapse (2011)
The 2011 season took a devastating turn for the Boston Red Sox. Leading the AL wild-card race in September, a late-season collapse saw the Red Sox missing the playoffs, leaving players and fans grappling with a stunning reversal of fortune. Watch here.
9. Jack Morris’s 10-Inning Shutout (1991)
In a pitching duel for the ages, Jack Morris’ extraordinary 10-inning shutout in Game 7 of the 1991 World Series left the Atlanta Braves defeated by the Minnesota Twins. It was a performance etched in baseball history, but one that brought heartbreak to Braves fans. Watch it here.
10. The Black Sox Scandal (1919)
A stain on the integrity of the game, the Black Sox Scandal of 1919 saw the Chicago White Sox intentionally losing the World Series. The fallout resulted in lifetime bans for eight players, forever altering the course of their careers and casting a shadow on baseball’s reputation.