23 MLB Hall of Famers Playing in Unusual Positions

Ever experienced that Twilight Zone-ish feeling while immersed in the world of baseball? Imagine a realm where the ordinary becomes extraordinary, where players defy the expected and redefine the game’s narrative. Now, picture Hall of Fame legends stepping into unusual positions, creating a surreal dimension within the ballpark.

Our post delves into the intriguing world of Hall of Famers who dared to step outside the boundaries of convention, showcasing the unusual positions they played and the indelible mark they left on the game.

These legendary players, typically associated with specific roles, showcased their versatility by deviating from the norm. Witnessing these Hall of Famers in unusual roles provides a fascinating glimpse into the multifaceted skills that these iconic players like brought to the game, adding layers of novelty to the sport for us fans while leaving indelible mark on baseball history.

This post contains affiliate links. Please read our disclosure.

1. Johnny Bench

Career: 1967–1983
Primary Position: Catcher

Johnny Bench, one of the greatest catchers in baseball history, ventured into unfamiliar territory during his fourth season in the majors in 1970, playing the outfield 24 times, including twice in center field—the only time in his career he would take on that position. That same season, he also made a single appearance at first base. Throughout his career, Bench would occasionally step in at third base, first base, and in the outfield, with roughly 25% of his career games played outside of catching. In 1982, as injuries began to take their toll, the Cincinnati Reds shifted him to third base in an effort to prolong his career and keep his bat in the lineup.

2. Roberto Clemente

Career: 1955–1972
Primary Position: Outfielder

Roberto Clemente, celebrated for his outfield prowess, exhibited an extraordinary versatility by briefly handling second base twice and third base once. Beyond his impact on the field, Clemente’s contributions to baseball extended to his unwavering dedication to humanitarian causes. Tragically, his life was cut short in a plane crash, leaving a poignant void in the baseball world and underscoring the loss of a remarkable athlete and philanthropist.

3. Gary Carter

Career: 1974–1992
Primary Position: Catcher

Gary Carter, who led a remarkable career as a catcher, demonstrated his versatility during a game against the Cincinnati Reds in 1986. Following a brawl, Carter found himself stepping into the unfamiliar territory of first base. This strategic move showcased not only his adaptability but also his commitment to the team’s success. Despite it being a one-time occurrence, Carter’s willingness to embrace an unusual position underscored his dedication to the game and his team. It stands as a testament to the unpredictable nature of baseball, where even Hall of Famers like Carter were willing to venture beyond their traditional roles for the sake of victory.

4. Cy Young

Career: 1890–1911
Primary Position: Pitcher

Cy Young, a legendary figure in baseball, not only left a legacy as an outfielder but also demonstrated his multifaceted skills on the pitcher’s mound. Beyond his renowned prowess in the outfield, Young made noteworthy contributions as a pitcher, showcasing the depth of his talent. Surprisingly, he also ventured into playing first base five times during his career, offering a glimpse into his versatility on the field. These instances, although relatively uncommon for a player of his caliber, add intriguing layers to Cy Young’s baseball narrative, revealing the diverse dimensions of his impact on the game.

5. Ryan Sandberg

Career: 1981–1997
Primary Position: Second Baseman

Ryan Sandberg, best known for his remarkable career as a second baseman, showcased his versatility by taking on 133 games at shortstop and 7 games at third base. This move away from his usual spot in the infield highlights Sandberg’s flexibility and dedication to supporting the team in any capacity. His proficiency in different defensive roles underscores his reputation as a player who went beyond conventional positions, leaving an enduring mark on the ever-evolving story of baseball.

6. Lou Gehrig

Career: 1923–1939
Primary Position: First Baseman

Lou Gehrig, renowned for his iconic role as a first baseman, demonstrated his versatility in a handful of games where he donned unusual positions. In a surprising twist, Gehrig took the field for six games as a right fielder, three games as a left fielder, and even once as a shortstop. These instances, though relatively rare, showcase Gehrig’s adaptability and willingness to embrace diverse roles within the game. Lou Gehrig’s career was filled with unforgettable moments that made him a legend in the eyes of baseball fans.

7. Tony Pérez

Career: 1964–1986
Primary Position: First Baseman

Tony Pérez, predominantly celebrated as a first baseman, ventured into the realm of second base for a single game, a departure from his customary role. This unique occurrence unfolded during a momentous game, showcasing Pérez’s versatility and readiness to step into unconventional positions when the team needed it most. While his legacy primarily rests on his powerful performances at first base, this brief stint at second base adds an intriguing chapter to Pérez’s illustrious career, reflecting his team-first mentality and dedication to contributing wherever his skills could make an impact.

8. Carlton Fisk

Career: 1969–1993
Primary Position: Catcher

Carlton Fisk, known for his exceptional career as a catcher with the Chicago White Sox, made a notable departure from his customary role by taking on the duties of a third baseman. This intriguing deviation from his usual position occurred during several seasons, adding a distinctive chapter to his Hall of Fame legacy. In the 1981, 1982, 1991, and 1987 seasons, Fisk seamlessly transitioned, for one game, to play first base. These instances showcase not only his prowess behind the plate but also his adaptability to contribute defensively in an unconventional position.

9. Ralph Kiner

Career: 1946–1955
Primary Position: Outfielder

Ralph Kiner was primarily an outfielder, but unexpectedly graced the first base position in 58 games and patrolled centerfield in 75 games. While his primary role was in the outfield, Kiner’s forays into first base and centerfield showcased his adaptability and utility for the team. These instances of playing in unusual positions underscore Kiner’s commitment to contributing wherever necessary, highlighting not just his offensive prowess but also his willingness to embrace different facets of the game for the collective benefit of the team.

10. Willie Mays

Career: 1948–1973
Primary Position: Outfielder

Legendary outfielder Willie Mays wasn’t afraid to break away from the expected norms of his position. In surprising moves, Mays took on the role of shortstop not once, but twice, and spent significant time at first base (84 games) and even tried his hand at third base for a game. The game in which he played shortstop was a 23-inning thriller against the Mets on May 31, 1964. Mays took the role of shortstop for three innings before heading back to centerfield for the rest of the game.

11. Johnny Mize

Career: 1936–1953
Primary Position: First Baseman

Johnny Mize, known primarily for his prowess as a first baseman, surprised fans on eight occasions by taking the field as an outfielder and, more specifically, as a right fielder. This departure from his usual infield role showcased Mize’s versatility and willingness to adapt to different positions. Whether stationed at first base or roaming the outfield, Mize’s impact was consistently felt, demonstrating that his skills extended beyond his designated area on the diamond. These instances added an element of unpredictability to Mize’s career and further solidified his place among baseball’s adaptable and talented players.

12. Wade Boggs

Career: 1982–1999
Primary Position: Third Baseman

Wade Boggs, primarily recognized as a standout third baseman, left an indelible mark on baseball history with a surprising stint on the pitcher’s mound. On Aug. 19, 1997, during a game with the Yankees trailing 12-7 in the eight inning against the Anaheim Angels, Boggs In his pitching debut, Boggs showcased a dancing knuckler, occasionally losing control but recovering to record two groundouts and a strikeout, stranding a runner. Two years later, at 41 with the Devil Rays, Boggs couldn’t replicate the magic, going 1 1/3 innings, yielding three hits, and conceding his first career earned run, yet managing to strike out another batter.

13. Ken Griffey Jr.

Career: 1989–2010
Primary Position: Outfielder

Ken Griffey Jr., widely celebrated for his brilliance in the outfield, made a notable shift to first base during his illustrious career. While primarily recognized for his outfield prowess, Griffey’s temporary stint at first base showcased his versatility and commitment to contributing wherever his team needed him. This positional adjustment revealed another dimension to Griffey’s skill set, proving that his impact on the game extended beyond his exceptional outfield abilities. Griffey’s willingness to embrace different roles on the field underscored his team-first mentality and added an intriguing chapter to his legendary baseball journey.

14. Hank Aaron

Career: 1954–1976
Primary Position: Right Fielder

Hank Aaron went beyond his famed home run record by showcasing remarkable versatility across different infield positions. In his illustrious career, Aaron spent a significant 210 games as a reliable first baseman. Moreover, he took on the challenges of second base 43 times and manned third base on seven occasions. Beyond his powerful swings and record-breaking achievements, Aaron’s ability to excel in diverse positions emphasized the depth of his impact on the sport. His legacy extends beyond the home run record, solidifying him as one of baseball’s most versatile and enduring figures, recognized for his multifaceted approach to the game.

15. Iván Rodríguez

Career: 1991–2011
Primary Position: Catcher

During his illustrious career primarily as a catcher, Iván Rodríguez showcased his versatility by occasionally taking on the role of a first baseman. While not a regular occurrence, Rodríguez’s foray into first base provided a strategic advantage during certain game situations. One notable instance was in a game against the Cincinnati Reds, where Rodríguez’s adaptability and defensive skills were on display as he seamlessly transitioned to first base. This move highlighted his commitment to contributing to the team’s success beyond his traditional position behind the plate. Despite being an unconventional sight, Rodríguez’s willingness to embrace different roles exemplified his dedication to the game and added another dimension to his Hall of Fame career.

16. Tony Gwynn

Career: 1982–2001
Primary Position: Right Fielder
Tony Gwynn was primarily known as an outfielder, though he played at left field much less frequently than the other outfield positions. During the 1982 and 1983 seasons, he played left field a total of fifty-one times. Later on in his career, in the 1998 season, he DH-ed for the first time, and would do so fourteen more times until retiring in 2001.

17. Mike Piazza

Career: 1992–2007
Primary Position: Catcher

Mike Piazza, renowned for his remarkable career as a catcher, ventured into an unusual position when he played first base. This deviation from his primary role occurred on select occasions, demonstrating Piazza’s adaptability on the field. One notable instance took place during his extensive career from 1992 to 2007. The decision to place Piazza at first base showcased not only his versatility but also his dedication to contributing wherever his team needed him.

18. Ty Cobb

Career: 1905-1928
Primary Position: Outfielder

Ty Cobb, a legendary figure in baseball history, primarily made his mark as an outfielder, known for his exceptional hitting prowess and base-stealing abilities. While predominantly recognized for his offensive skills, Cobb’s willingness to step into different defensive roles highlighted his commitment to the team’s success. He was called up three times to pitch–twice in the 1918 season, when he pitch a total of four innings. He also earned a save with one inning pitched in the 1925. Cobb also played fourteen games at first base, two games at second base, and one at third base. These unconventional moves provided fans with a rare glimpse of Cobb’s adaptability, proving that even baseball’s most iconic figures were not confined to a single position on the diamond.

19. Adrián Beltré

Career: 1998-2018
Primary Position: Outfielder

On January 23rd, 2023, Adrián Beltré was elected to the Hall of Fame with 95.1% of the vote on the first ballot. Beltrán was dependable both as a hitter and fielder. Beltré, who played 18 seasons for four teams, and was an All-Star in 2010, played primarily as a third baseman. In a game in 2006, though while with the Seattle Mariners, he played second base. Many of Beltré’s long time fans might be surprised at this turn of events for the iconic player. It shows just how a remarkable and versatile player he was, even though he played at this unusual position for only one game.

20. Paul Molitor

Career: 1978-1998
Primary Position: Second Baseman and Third Baseman

Paul Molitorto, although he was known primarily for his defensive skills as a second and third baseman, played four games as a left fielder and four as right fielder. The former occurred during the 1981 season and the latter in 1986. The 1991 season is when he would also switch over to the role of first baseman, and would not play at another position since. In 1981 he would play 42 games as a center fielder. He would also assume the role of shortstop 52 times, mostly during his second season, where he played at that position 31 times.

21. Ricky Henderson

Career: 1979-2003
Primary Position: Left Fielder

Ricky Henderson is known primarily for his duties as a left fielder. In one game in 1979 he played at right field and wouldn’t play at the position until 1996, while with the San Diego padres. The following year, he would play in the position 18 more times; in total, Henderson has played at right field 27 times. From 1985 until 1987, while with the Yankees, Henderson would assume the role of center fielder, before switching back to left field, where he would remain for most of his career. The first time I ever saw a live game at Yankee Stadium was on June 25, 1985; the Yankees were hosting the Baltimore Orioles. The game summary reveals that day, Ricky Henderson played center field. I didn’t recall much of that game, but it was nice to learn this while researching for this blog post.

22. Eddie Murray

Career: 1977-1997
Primary Position: First Baseman

During his first year with the Baltimore orioles, in 1977, Eddie Murray played six games in the outfield, the only time he would ever do so. The next year, he played at the position three more times. Then in 1989 and 1991, while with the Dodgers, he was positioned thrice mote at third base for a total of six times that Murray has played at the position.

23. Alan Trammell

Career: 1977–1996
Primary Position: Short Stop

Alan Trammell was known primarily as a shortstop, although later in his career he would assumed the role of third baseman, second baseman, center fielder, and right fielder on a number of occasions. The 1993 and 1996 seasons (the last of his career) is when he would assume these unusual roles. In 1996, he would play at center field and left field four times, and once more at center field in his final year. He would also play forty-three times at third base and eleven times at second. He also DH-ed sixty times.